TOPIC: Reprint requests of any rarity for 2025

Exbalz wrote:

David Harris wrote: Ring or Amulet of Wonder, due to the recent news.

+1

No need. There are so many amulets and rings out there that there will still be plenty of rings and amulets after all
The totems are made.

Endgame wrote:

Exbalz wrote:

David Harris wrote: Ring or Amulet of Wonder, due to the recent news.

+1

No need. There are so many amulets and rings out there that there will still be plenty of rings and amulets after all
The totems are made.

At the time of posting this, I'm going to apply the same analysis I apply to all reprints that I recommend, so let's see how the wonder effect items compare:

Ring of Wonder: First printed in 2020, so that's a little early for a reprint compared to what we've seen in recent years. Currently available through vendor websites (Trent, Kirk, Utaku): Onyx - 2 at $142.50 and $150. Gold - 1 at $125, 3 at $95. Overall, coming in higher than current PYP price, but not egregious. As a reprint candidate, there's better targets.

Amulet of Wonder: 2008 and 2013, printed twice, but it was last printed 11 years ago. Currently available through vendor websites (Trent, Kirk, Utaku): Onyx - 0, Gold - 1 at $85, 2 at $175, 4 at $179. Once someone snaps off that last $85 token we're well into reprint candidate territoy. Will that price pull back some? Potentially if the hype around the new legendary dies down, but highly unlikely it drops below $125.

There's certainly room to argue against reprinting these tokens, but I think it's safe to say there's more than zero need. There's currently only 13 more potential wonder effects available when earlier today they were widely available for $25-$30. This tells me that TPTB would be supported if they are interested in making the Wonder effect available either for newer players that want the effect and are willing to use a slot or anyone who missed out on the gold rush this afternoon.

I'm likely not making one of these so I don't particularly have a dog in this fight, but if someone missed the two hour window of getting their reasonably priced Wonder effect and could be forced into making an Omni Orb to get their new fun shiny token, that would be a bit of a feel bad.

There are far more people with tokens than just resellers with websites.

RoW killed AoW's value. Wasn't much reason to try to sell or trade away AoW until now, so folks will come out of the woodwork like, um, me.

Exbalz wrote:

Endgame wrote:

Exbalz wrote:

David Harris wrote: Ring or Amulet of Wonder, due to the recent news.

+1

No need. There are so many amulets and rings out there that there will still be plenty of rings and amulets after all
The totems are made.

At the time of posting this, I'm going to apply the same analysis I apply to all reprints that I recommend, so let's see how the wonder effect items compare:

Ring of Wonder: First printed in 2020, so that's a little early for a reprint compared to what we've seen in recent years. Currently available through vendor websites (Trent, Kirk, Utaku): Onyx - 2 at $142.50 and $150. Gold - 1 at $125, 3 at $95. Overall, coming in higher than current PYP price, but not egregious. As a reprint candidate, there's better targets.

Amulet of Wonder: 2008 and 2013, printed twice, but it was last printed 11 years ago. Currently available through vendor websites (Trent, Kirk, Utaku): Onyx - 0, Gold - 1 at $85, 2 at $175, 4 at $179. Once someone snaps off that last $85 token we're well into reprint candidate territoy. Will that price pull back some? Potentially if the hype around the new legendary dies down, but highly unlikely it drops below $125.

There's certainly room to argue against reprinting these tokens, but I think it's safe to say there's more than zero need. There's currently only 13 more potential wonder effects available when earlier today they were widely available for $25-$30. This tells me that TPTB would be supported if they are interested in making the Wonder effect available either for newer players that want the effect and are willing to use a slot or anyone who missed out on the gold rush this afternoon.

I'm likely not making one of these so I don't particularly have a dog in this fight, but if someone missed the two hour window of getting their reasonably priced Wonder effect and could be forced into making an Omni Orb to get their new fun shiny token, that would be a bit of a feel bad.

Personally I think more would be wasted vs used in reprint. These wonder tokens need 40 other bits to make this wonder totem. Unless there is extreme demand for the necklace / ring as stand alone, I would vote against a reprint for 2025. An Omni orb can go in place. I did a 3 part analysis based off the cost of TG using the spreadsheet that tracks the value of TG and the PyP for each year and gives us the avg high, low and average over 5 Auctions. If you had no components of the Omni Orb, and had to buy then via Auctions ( cost of GF included but can’t buy in Auctions ), it would cost $172.50. Which is on the high end but not completely out there. There are many that fit the reprint requirements and exceeds $400+ and that’s at a minimum. I could be alone in this thought, and always, if there are many who need these wonder tokens for totems & just to use the wonder effect in either the neck or ring slot… then I would probably advise a small print run. Next year has bead # 2 and I would bet if they do a reprint, they would go through 1/2 of them as PyP. If I’m wrong then I will gladly see it differently if the need for these are great. But I think they push should be reprint for stand alone use, not as ingredients for the totem. That’s exactly why TDA created the OMNI orb and cube.

I hope that the Ring or Amulet of Wonder aren't reprinted. There was already very low demand for them based on competition in those two slots, and the new token will completely obsolete them for anyone that gets it. It doesn't seem worth reprinting them almost solely as an ingredient for the new Legendary token. There are likely plenty of Rings and Amulets of Wonder available, and even if not the Omni Orbs can be used for the transmute.

I'm hoping that the Omni Orb has eliminated the need to ever reprint a UR strictly for a Legendary recipe.

Please reprint the Ioun Stone Silver Nugget. Its the last one I need and I just can't justify spending over $300 for it. Lots of people missed the boat on that one.

It would be nice to reprint necklace of the Songbird. It's high demand and low supply, and was never in 10 packs for Dungeon runs.

Mike Steele wrote: It would be nice to reprint necklace of the Songbird. It's high demand and low supply, and was never in 10 packs for Dungeon runs.

Also Crown of Focus from 2021, same reasons.

If we’re looking at 2021 reprints, let’s put Beryl Prism on the list. It’s a staple and 21 didn’t really get it out in the wild

Potion Leaping Attack (2017) - It's on theme.

Let’s leave potion leaping attack on the “never reprint” list. Winged boots that let you make an attack 1/room vs flying monsters might be good though

Endgame wrote: Let’s leave potion leaping attack on the “never reprint” list. Winged boots that let you make an attack 1/room vs flying monsters might be good though

-1 I would like to see it reprinted every few years