TOPIC: Reprint requests of any rarity for 2025

BeLinda Mathie wrote:

OrionW wrote: Scroll Loki’s Blessing

I am almost out and this is definitely the most appropriate theme to add a reprint in!

+1, can't believe I didn't mention this one.

+3 (ie third +1) this would fit thematically and helps parties of all difficulty levels.

Fred K wrote:

Mike Steele wrote:

Picc wrote: Scroll Detect Magic
Scroll Detect Secret Doors
Scroll Light
Scroll Mirror Image
Scroll Purify Food & Drink

Weighted Net

+1 for Carter’s Tome

Per tokendb, Scroll Light is obsolete. It must be one of the rarest tokens, as it was only in the 2003 set.

I thought the light ruling wasn’t until a few years into the game. I bet I have a dozen of those - if anyone is looking for one, they are available for trade.

Fred, you are correct, it was a valid token for several years. At that time, the party got one torch, and a light token (or similar tokens) would get an additional light. It was REALLY hard to see in some of those rooms with just one light source for the party. It became obsolete once everyone in the party started getting their own individual light sources.

Reprint it with the ability to blind an opponent. Or give some bonus to puzzles (perhaps mitigate a point or two of failure damage, not push).
Cool, useful and pulls the old token forward.

raptorov wrote: Reprint it with the ability to blind an opponent. Or give some bonus to puzzles (perhaps mitigate a point or two of failure damage, not push).
Cool, useful and pulls the old token forward.

I'd love to do that with Rumor tokens. Reprint those, and do something fun with them. It could be as simple as turn them in during the room to get a clue of some sort. It could be easy to implement, each room could just have one rumor to hand out per Dungeon.

I'm not as enthusiastic about reprinting URs, because more often than not it seems to tank the value of both the older version and the new printing. But there are some that still are great candidates.

Relics:
Greater Cloak of Destiny
Ring of Greater Focus

UR:
+2 Assassins Crossbow
+2 Rod of Persuasion
Carter's Tome of Insight
Figurine of Power Panther
Gloves of the Flying Fist
Bowl of Spirit Sight
Figurine of Power Owl
Ioun Stone Topaz Trilliant
Greater Holy Symbol of Pelor (maybe functional reprint)

Rare:
Charm of Enlightenment
Rumor (with a fun use)

payden wrote: -A refresh of the cabal items would be good

+1

Mike Steele wrote:

Fred K wrote:

Mike Steele wrote:

Picc wrote: Scroll Detect Magic
Scroll Detect Secret Doors
Scroll Light
Scroll Mirror Image
Scroll Purify Food & Drink

Weighted Net

+1 for Carter’s Tome

Per tokendb, Scroll Light is obsolete. It must be one of the rarest tokens, as it was only in the 2003 set.

I thought the light ruling wasn’t until a few years into the game. I bet I have a dozen of those - if anyone is looking for one, they are available for trade.

Fred, you are correct, it was a valid token for several years. At that time, the party got one torch, and a light token (or similar tokens) would get an additional light. It was REALLY hard to see in some of those rooms with just one light source for the party. It became obsolete once everyone in the party started getting their own individual light sources.

If light came back with a chippie reprint I'm sure we could come up with something for it to do in the modern dungeon. Perhaps a puzzle where more light granted a mechanical advantage or something in grind

I get the feeling that if a party came up with some creative way to use Scroll: Light in a dungeon and it made sense, that most DMs would allow it.

Probably too soon but Charm of Quick Strike

Charm of Brooching.

Though the last gap was 6 years, so maybe 2026 makes more sense.

Ring or Amulet of Wonder, due to the recent news.

David Harris wrote: Ring or Amulet of Wonder, due to the recent news.

+1