TOPIC: 2020 Transmute Recipes, From the QTR

Gem of Last Hope now requires 500 GP instead of 1,000 GP.

Druegar wrote: Cut-off is end of day today: Friday, September 13, 2019.
Tell me specifically what needs to be changed before this goes to the printer and is forever immutable.
Vagaries and petty whining will be blithely ignored.

can't tell if directed at me

Druegar wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote: I propose -5 minotaur hide and -5 dwarven steel from each of the relic and legendary recipes. In turn, I propose +5 darkwoord plank, +5 Mystic Silk, and +5 Philosopher's Stone.

done

Awesome!

Thank you very much.

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Druegar wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote: I propose -5 minotaur hide and -5 dwarven steel from each of the relic and legendary recipes. In turn, I propose +5 darkwoord plank, +5 Mystic Silk, and +5 Philosopher's Stone.

done

Awesome!

Thank you very much.

thank you Wade for the specific and well stated rationale for the change.

thank you Dreugar for agreeing to the change. Lowering DS and MH by 5 was exactly the amount I felt they were overstated. They are still a significant requirement, but more in line with an amount that is reasonably attainable.

Druegar wrote: Gem of Last Hope now requires 500 GP instead of 1,000 GP.

I’d still like to see half the trade goods dropped from this recipe. It is way too resource intensive for a one use item in my opinion. I know I will not be making any at the current price.

Wayne Rhodes wrote:

Druegar wrote: Gem of Last Hope now requires 500 GP instead of 1,000 GP.

I’d still like to see half the trade goods dropped from this recipe. It is way too resource intensive for a one use item in my opinion. I know I will not be making any at the current price.

I will make at least 1, probably a couple.
The trade good cost seems fine to me, and is the part that I mind the least.
The monster bit seems a reasonable part of the request. If there were no GP I would like it more, but I doubt that will happen.

What I would like to see is if we could choose a rare other than earcuff of vitality to go along with the potion deaths door or revival root.

Reasoning is, earcuff of vitality is likely to be a sought after rare regardless of its inclusion in this recipe or not, as new players like HP, and we vets like to help newer players.
Also, earcuff of vitality was already in the Icecrag Hero's Earcuff recipe and is relatively scarce, hence the need for a reprint.
I would suggest swapping earcuff of vitality for either bracers of the toad, figurine of power: moon beetle, or ioun stone tourmaline tear

Would recommend bracers of the toad, particularly with bracers of the tavern keeper on the horizon.

Druegar wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote: I propose -5 minotaur hide and -5 dwarven steel from each of the relic and legendary recipes. In turn, I propose +5 darkwoord plank, +5 Mystic Silk, and +5 Philosopher's Stone.

done

Huzzah!

I would like to see allowing any 2020 monster bit as an option instaed of just 2019 monster bits for the Gem.

Someone want to wrangle up Incognito and have him make any input he might have before the deadline, not after.

No, I am not salty at all....lol.

jedibcg wrote: Someone want to wrangle up Incognito and have him make any input he might have before the deadline, not after.

Nope.

macXdmg wrote: can't tell if directed at me

It was directed at everyone in general and no one specific.

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Wayne Rhodes wrote:

Druegar wrote: Gem of Last Hope now requires 500 GP instead of 1,000 GP.

I’d still like to see half the trade goods dropped from this recipe. It is way too resource intensive for a one use item in my opinion. I know I will not be making any at the current price.

I will make at least 1, probably a couple.
The trade good cost seems fine to me, and is the part that I mind the least.
The monster bit seems a reasonable part of the request. If there were no GP I would like it more, but I doubt that will happen.

What I would like to see is if we could choose a rare other than earcuff of vitality to go along with the potion deaths door or revival root.

Reasoning is, earcuff of vitality is likely to be a sought after rare regardless of its inclusion in this recipe or not, as new players like HP, and we vets like to help newer players.
Also, earcuff of vitality was already in the Icecrag Hero's Earcuff recipe and is relatively scarce, hence the need for a reprint.
I would suggest swapping earcuff of vitality for either bracers of the toad, figurine of power: moon beetle, or ioun stone tourmaline tear

Would recommend bracers of the toad, particularly with bracers of the tavern keeper on the horizon.

Dropping the monster bit would be better than dropping the trade goods at this point. And I agree something other than the Earcuff would be nice given that it’s such a good token for newer players.