TOPIC: Kurtreznor's review

MasterED wrote:

kurtreznor wrote: Oh, one more thing i wanted to comment on...
Auction
I really like that the auction came back, hopefully we will see more small prop items in future auctions. Could TD allow non-trade bar GP for any bids under 5k? That would allow more involvement of players with little GP, remove the minimum of 1k, and allow much smaller items (i won a set of rogue clues one year for about 100gp because noone was bidding on them).

Yes, but we are going to put an age limit on the bidders!

Seriously, the plan is to offer two types of auctions. One where the items will be bid on by players like this year and one where you can buy raffle tickets for say 200GP each and then put them in buckets based upon the item being auctioned. This way even someone with 200GP could win an item and not be out bid by a Gold Goblin.

Ed

I love the idea of a gp raffle!

Picc wrote:

MasterED wrote:

kurtreznor wrote: Oh, one more thing i wanted to comment on...
Auction
I really like that the auction came back, hopefully we will see more small prop items in future auctions. Could TD allow non-trade bar GP for any bids under 5k? That would allow more involvement of players with little GP, remove the minimum of 1k, and allow much smaller items (i won a set of rogue clues one year for about 100gp because noone was bidding on them).

Yes, but we are going to put an age limit on the bidders!

Seriously, the plan is to offer two types of auctions. One where the items will be bid on by players like this year and one where you can buy raffle tickets for say 200GP each and then put them in buckets based upon the item being auctioned. This way even someone with 200GP could win an item and not be out bid by a Gold Goblin.

Ed

I love the idea of a gp raffle!

Me too

Eldar wrote: N1 Room 7: Ring of Pandemonium actually doesn't help here as apparently it has an errata to only include spells involving disintegration per one of the Valkyrie DMs from the room.

I don’t see anything about an errata... I think the DM was in error...

There is nothing about changing the token On TokenDB

Nothing about spells... the text is still “Wearer gains immunity to confusion, disintegrate, and maze spells.”

Am I missing something?

Mongo wrote:

Eldar wrote: N1 Room 7: Ring of Pandemonium actually doesn't help here as apparently it has an errata to only include spells involving disintegration per one of the Valkyrie DMs from the room.

I don’t see anything about an errata... I think the DM was in error...

There is nothing about changing the token On TokenDB

Nothing about spells... the text is still “Wearer gains immunity to confusion, disintegrate, and maze spells.”

Am I missing something?

I am going to make an educated guess. Someone used the Ring and the DM/AC didn't like it bypassing the puzzle so they change the wording in the puzzle off of disintegrate. Just a guess though.

Ed

Bob Chasan wrote:

Picc wrote:

MasterED wrote:

kurtreznor wrote: Oh, one more thing i wanted to comment on...
Auction
I really like that the auction came back, hopefully we will see more small prop items in future auctions. Could TD allow non-trade bar GP for any bids under 5k? That would allow more involvement of players with little GP, remove the minimum of 1k, and allow much smaller items (i won a set of rogue clues one year for about 100gp because noone was bidding on them).

Yes, but we are going to put an age limit on the bidders!

Seriously, the plan is to offer two types of auctions. One where the items will be bid on by players like this year and one where you can buy raffle tickets for say 200GP each and then put them in buckets based upon the item being auctioned. This way even someone with 200GP could win an item and not be out bid by a Gold Goblin.

Ed

I love the idea of a gp raffle!

Me too

Not me. I wouldn’t mind if it was part of it, but i would hate if all the “good stuff” like the oversized-token was raffle-only.

E.g. there could have been a raffle for some of the ten Kvothes.

Brad Mortensen wrote:

Bob Chasan wrote:

Picc wrote:

MasterED wrote:

kurtreznor wrote:
Seriously, the plan is to offer two types of auctions. One where the items will be bid on by players like this year and one where you can buy raffle tickets for say 200GP each and then put them in buckets based upon the item being auctioned. This way even someone with 200GP could win an item and not be out bid by a Gold Goblin.

Ed

I love the idea of a gp raffle!

Me too

Not me. I wouldn’t mind if it was part of it, but i would hate if all the “good stuff” like the oversized-token was raffle-only.

E.g. there could have been a raffle for some of the ten Kvothes.

Brad,
I agree wholeheartedly and from the post I assumed it would only be a small part of the auction but enough to get more people involved.

Bob Chasan wrote: I agree wholeheartedly and from the post I assumed it would only be a small part of the auction but enough to get more people involved.

Correct.

Ed