TOPIC: 2019 Ultra-Rare Token Suggestions

Matthew Hayward wrote:

MasterED wrote: Adding a token where you could heal allies multiple times a room shouldn't happen (unless it is Bard, Cleric, Druid).

Ed

And Paladin?

Yep, sorry forgot my Paladin brothers - updated.

Ed

MasterED wrote:
Adding a token where you could heal allies multiple times a room shouldn't happen (unless it is Bard, Cleric, Druid, Paladin).

Ed

I think it would be cool and an interesting option. I'm not sure why it shouldn't happen.

To each their own, I suppose.

Phrash wrote:

MasterED wrote:
Adding a token where you could heal allies multiple times a room shouldn't happen (unless it is Bard, Cleric, Druid, Paladin).

Ed

I think it would be cool and an interesting option. I'm not sure why it shouldn't happen.

To each their own, I suppose.

I understand why might think that but this isn't an MMORP. Think about what would happen if there was a token that...

• Let any class do the Rogue Box?
• Let any class cast damage spells?
• Let any class cast healing spells?
• Let any class dual slide?
• Let any class guard other players?

People have these tokens then we would all have universal classes and there would be any distinguishing abilities.

The best balance, in my opinion, is to have one class that is the best, another that can do it but not nearly as well, and lastly a possible third class that could do it once.

Ed

MasterED wrote:

Phrash wrote:

MasterED wrote:
Adding a token where you could heal allies multiple times a room shouldn't happen (unless it is Bard, Cleric, Druid, Paladin).

Ed

I think it would be cool and an interesting option. I'm not sure why it shouldn't happen.

To each their own, I suppose.

I understand why might think that but this isn't an MMORP. Think about what would happen if there was a token that...

• Let any class do the Rogue Box?
• Let any class cast damage spells?
• Let any class cast healing spells?
• Let any class dual slide?
• Let any class guard other players?

People have these tokens then we would all have universal classes and there would be any distinguishing abilities.

The best balance, in my opinion, is to have one class that is the best, another that can do it but not nearly as well, and lastly a possible third class that could do it once.

Ed

I would still be excited to see a token like this if it was self healing. Maybe at +3?

I understand your opinion, but I do not agree that the ally healing would be extreme enough that it would be encroaching on other class roles (which, again, is obviously my opinion). But if TPTB do not want to see ally healing in this fashion, I am cool with that.

I don't understand the relevance of the comment:

MasterED wrote: but this isn't an MMORP

but maybe I am missing something.

Phrash wrote:

MasterED wrote: but this isn't an MMORP

but maybe I am missing something.

In an MMORP many classes overlap (e.g. in WoW a Monk or Paladin can all be Tank, DPS, or Healer). They can electronically alter how each one does their role to create differences.

In TD we don't have an electronic combat/heal system so diversity is much more limited. Hope this clears up the statement.

Ed

MasterED wrote:

Phrash wrote:

MasterED wrote: but this isn't an MMORP

but maybe I am missing something.

In an MMORP many classes overlap (e.g. in WoW a Monk or Paladin can all be Tank, DPS, or Healer). They can electronically alter how each one does their role to create differences.

In TD we don't have an electronic combat/heal system so diversity is much more limited. Hope this clears up the statement.

Ed

It does, thank you.