TOPIC: Feedback Needed: 2014 Transmuted Recipes!

Oil of Enchantment seems a touch over required as well, should consider switching some to elven bismuth so its more of an even split overall.

valetutto wrote: Oil of Enchantment seems a touch over required as well, should consider switching some to elven bismuth so its more of an even split overall.

Actually at the relic level, there are fewer oils needed than bismuths overall. Oils are used in the Rings and bow, and bismuths in all of the weapons. Makes sense to me. No idea on the legendary recipes, though - I don't even think about them.

My only issue is the GP cost for the Relic Longbow - 5000GP? That puts it outside of the range for most 1K buyers if that was the only Relic they wanted to build. Still if it is considered on par with the Supreme Ring of Evasion I guess I will have to live with it. Sure it can't come down to 4000GP, at least then there is a chance with a condensed pack to get it out of the gate.

Perhaps add a few more Enchanted Munitions to the formula to offset?

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

Thanks, Druegar! That is why I was recommending saying common healing tokens, so you could pull in tokens like the Orcish Rations and Dwarven Rations. They were the common "Potion of Healing" equivalent for those years.

valetutto wrote: Am I the only one that thinkgs the 100gp value on the healing potion is high?

I'm totally cool with needing 11 points but I think the GP value should be closer to 50.

---


Other recepies looks pretty good, Philisopher stones might be a touch high.

I share the concerns of the Dagger costing extra specific URs, makes the choice to upgrade from Relic to Legendary, more immediate which is not always a good thing.

Maybe change it to requiring 15 points of healing from any combination of tokens, and eliminate the GP requirement?

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

For the Barbarian, that's just mom's cooking. LOL

Brad Mortensen wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote:

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

then we should be fine saying TD token that heals 1HP

So I can't send in a half-bottle of Nyquil. Check.

Nor a full bottle...

Harlax wrote:

Brad Mortensen wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote:

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

then we should be fine saying TD token that heals 1HP

So I can't send in a half-bottle of Nyquil. Check.

No, NyQuil cures 3 HP, but you take an initiative penalty for drowsiness.

DayQuil is the 1 HP version.

But you can't trade DayQuil either.

What if we write "TD token" on it?

although, they'd be too expensive to ship, and too likely to break in transit...not to mention costing more than the 1hp token... hmmm, did I just say something rational in my joking?...shame on me...

Mike Steele wrote:

valetutto wrote: Am I the only one that thinkgs the 100gp value on the healing potion is high?

I'm totally cool with needing 11 points but I think the GP value should be closer to 50.

---


Other recepies looks pretty good, Philisopher stones might be a touch high.

I share the concerns of the Dagger costing extra specific URs, makes the choice to upgrade from Relic to Legendary, more immediate which is not always a good thing.

Maybe change it to requiring 15 points of healing from any combination of tokens, and eliminate the GP requirement?

That would be ok. The 100gp is going to be 2 uncommons gold for most people which could be 2 uncommon heals in the scheme of things. Going up on the healing and down on the GP works out better in the wash.

greyseer wrote:
Perhaps add a few more Enchanted Munitions to the formula to offset?

Oh no please no. We're comming off a stent of low ammunitions, now is not the time to increase the need for them.

My 2 cents:

1. Would love to be able to use other healing potion to create distilled healing

2. Some of the recipes seems a bit much. 2 Aragonite for a Relic is rather steep.

valetutto wrote:

greyseer wrote:
Perhaps add a few more Enchanted Munitions to the formula to offset?

Oh no please no. We're comming off a stent of low ammunitions, now is not the time to increase the need for them.

I agree with Valetutto, Enchanted Munitions is extremly difficult. Though I did see some on eBay this weekend.