TOPIC: Feedback Needed: 2014 Transmuted Recipes!

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i am still going with either lower Aragonite for the legendary or get rid of the extra UR requirements

Agreed, The ingredient cost is just too high with the need for UR tokens.

If an Ultra Rare needs to be used in the creation of these legendary weapons it should be non specific URs from any year. Maybe make it "Any Edged UR Weapon." for the sword and dagger.

quip wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote:

Harlax wrote: Am I missing something or wouldn't saying "any potion that heals 1 hp" work?

I don't see anything wrong with your wording other than adding any TD potion token that heals one HP.

Wait, I wouldn't be able to use my old Neverwinter Nights 1hp potions?!?!? But I have at least a thousand in the file I could email in! And I have lots of gp in the file too!

Joking aside, I would hope no one would try to send in something other than a TD token. I agree, adding the phrase "TD potion token" makes it crystal clear.

Out of curiosity, I wonder if anyone has attempted to send in illegitimate gp before...
I have faith in the intelligence of the TD community being much higher than that.

it popped in my head(i thought about doing that) that is why I added it

Mike Steele wrote:

Harlax wrote: Am I missing something or wouldn't saying "any potion that heals 1 hp" work?

There are other older common healing tokens that don't heal a straight 1 point, maybe they heal 2 with a disadvantage. I'd recommend including all older common healing tokens, it's not that long of a list.

i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

although I have not checked the Tokendatabase

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

then we should be fine saying TD token that heals 1HP

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote:

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

then we should be fine saying TD token that heals 1HP

So I can't send in a half-bottle of Nyquil. Check.

Brad Mortensen wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote:

Druegar wrote:

lazlo_hollyfeld1985 wrote: i dont think there was a potion that healed one HP and did something bad

Orcish Rations is a Common that heals 1 HP and has a negative side-effect, but it's not a "potion".

then we should be fine saying TD token that heals 1HP

So I can't send in a half-bottle of Nyquil. Check.

No, NyQuil cures 3 HP, but you take an initiative penalty for drowsiness.

DayQuil is the 1 HP version.

But you can't trade DayQuil either.

Can we make it so the potion takes 11 points of any healing item, I would gladly turn all of this years rare potions into the Potion of Distilled Healing

commanderFuron wrote: Can we make it so the potion takes 11 points of any healing item, I would gladly turn all of this years rare potions into the Potion of Distilled Healing

I don't think that will happen. I agree on this years rare potions.
I am glad I saved last years.

What would have been interesting would have been transmuting an Alchemist Ink into two Potion of Distilled Healing.

One drawback to the current recipe is that it's a one-shot. After Oasis Waters roll out the PoDH is done. Would have been nice to have it hang around yearlessly like other trade tokens...

I think that asking for 2 Aragonite for Relic level items is way too much. Current Legendary items ask for 2 Aragonite, don't bump Relics up to that level.

Other item specifics:
-Asking for 8 Minotaur Hide on the +3 Slayer Sword is too much. Cut that by half, if not all the way down to 2 Minotaur Hide. It's a sword, not a piece of armor or even a weapon that might be more hide oriented, like a staff.

-Asking for 8 Dwarven Steel on the +2 Keen Slayer Bow is too much. Same principal as above: cut that by half, if not all the way down to 2 Dwarven Steel. It's a bow, not a piece of armor or a sword.


So..... yeah, other than a few item quibbles and the excessive amount of Aragonite being asked for on Relics, all else looks okay to me.

Am I the only one that thinkgs the 100gp value on the healing potion is high?

I'm totally cool with needing 11 points but I think the GP value should be closer to 50.

---


Other recepies looks pretty good, Philisopher stones might be a touch high.

I share the concerns of the Dagger costing extra specific URs, makes the choice to upgrade from Relic to Legendary, more immediate which is not always a good thing.