TOPIC: This is not the Post you are looking for Henwy. Move along.

<br />No love for the rogue (removed it for the Faerie-Iron Club).  Not sure the justification here (other than more powerful than a short sword).  Seems to me a club is a rogue weapon.<br />

<br /><br />I was thinking about suggesting a "sap" for rogues- 1,2,3,4 Only usable with sneak attack, Usable only against humanoids, 20 results in unconsciousness. But there were a lot of "on a 20" type weapons this year already.

<br />For the Cestus do you really mean that any successful hit reduces AC or only on a CRIT?<br /><br />

<br /><br />Any hit.  Basically, you are trading in some damage potential for reducing the monster's AC.  It is kind of an ingenious move that SeyLah would probably make.

Trading damage potential to lower enemy AC is a logical and selfless move when it is 8 on 1. On the other hand, the enemy AC can be set so high that losing a few means very little.

<br /><br />I also asked before if the monk could use 2 SeyLah's Cestuses.  Still curious to what the answer is.<br /><br />

<br /><br />Yes, a Monk could be a AC lowering machine.  The only problem I can see is what slot(s) this thing will take up.  By the look of it, it should take up both a hand and a forearm slot.  But maybe we could fudge it a bit and just say hand slot.  I could not find a good cestus photo!

The new tokens are looking great! Big thanks for adding the form into the Polymorph title. It looks much better now. The Pugio also looks better at the reduced size. Now the +1 Pugio needs the same treatment.<br /><br />Here's my new list of tweaks. I'll keep coming up with them until someone tells me to shut up or I can't find any more.  =D<br /><br />Currently I see two different 'All except' class restriction wordings:<br />'Usable by all except X'<br />Darkwood Shillelagh<br />Obsidian Dagger<br />Silver Sickle<br />Faerie-Iron Club<br />+2 Dagger of Venom<br /><br />'All except X'<br />Pugio<br />+1 Pugio<br /><br />Should really go with one or the other. I think I prefer the more concise one.<br /><br />Similarly with tokens requiring saves. I see:<br />DC-15 Fort save - Summon Insects<br />Fort DC-12 save - Sling Bullet of Stunning<br />Will DC-12 save - Hat of Escape<br /><br />The version on Summon Insects makes the most sense to me.<br /><br /><br />All Shurikens - Class list is not in alphabetic order, should be 'Fighter, Monk & Rogue'<br /><br />Masterwork Arrow - should say '+1 to damage' to match up with the wording on +1/+2 Arrow<br />Obsidian Dagger - how about a more concise wording, something like 'Breaks after 1 combat'?<br />Scroll Acid Spray - should have a 'Does' at the beginning of the description to match up with Melf's Acid Arrow<br />Skunkweed - probably needs a '(One use)' like Belladonna<br />Spiked Buckler - should say '+1 to AC'<br /><br />Cap of the Owl - 'Saves' shouldn't be capitalized<br />Oakspirit Armor - should say '+7 to AC'<br />Scythe - Class list is not in alphabetic order, should be 'Barbarian, Druid, Fighter & Paladin'<br />Sling Bullets - should say '+2 x damage' to match up with the seasonal runestones and masterwork/+1/+2 arrows<br />Trident - Class list is not in alphabetic order, should be 'Barbarian & Fighter'<br />Wolf Totem Armor - should say '+4 to AC', also needs a '&' between the 2 effects. Could the class listing be along the curved edge like common armors with the same class usage?<br /><br />Faerie-Iron Shield - 'vs' needs a period after it<br />Amulet of Thorns - 'pts' needs a period fater it and should have a 'Does' at the beginning of the description to match up with Fireshield<br />Faerie-Iron Armor - 'vs' needs a period after it<br />Helm of the Boar - should say '+2 to melee damage & -4 to Reflex saves'<br />Pilum of Lightning  - Class list is not in alphabetic order, should be 'Barbarian, Bard, Fighter, Paladin, Ranger & Rogue'<br />+1 Kopis - needs a '&' in the class list between Paladin and Ranger<br />Commander's Lorica Segmenta - looks like a space is needed between 'to' and 'AC' on the first line and 'vs' needs a period after it<br />Oil of Smiting - the numbers 19 and 20 should probably be written with double-quotes around them to match up with other tokens (Dagger of Venom, Questor's Charm, etc.)<br />Scroll Mass Cure Minor Wounds - 'point' should be abbreviated 'pt.' to match up with other healing items<br />Sling Bullet of Thunder - should say '+4 sonic damage' to match up with the seasonal runestones and masterwork/+1/+2 arrows<br /><br />Crown of Might - how about '+1 to hit & damage in melee'?<br />Dragonscale Shield - needs a '&' between the two effects<br />Plate Armor of Absorption - needs a '&' between the two effects<br />SeyLah's +2 Sundering Cestus - needs a period after 'pt'<br />Ring of Fire Elemental Command - can we update the third part of the description to 'does 2 pts. fire damage to any monster that hits wearer in melee' to match Scroll Fireshield? It might not fit, but if it does it would be nice.<br /><br />Looking at the ultra-rares I see three different wordings for 'damage resistance' effects.<br />-1 from fire damage<br />-1 damage from melee hits<br />-5 to fire damage<br /><br />How about:<br />-1 damage from fire<br />-1 damage from melee<br />-5 damage from fire<br /><br />Or we could just add a DR 'rule':<br />+1 to fire DR<br />+1 to melee DR<br />+5 to fire DR<br /><br />Whew...  =)

Don't stop. Your reviews are thorough and necessary. Do you need a job (lol)?

BTW, I will change the Boots of the Underdark already.

<br />Yes, a Monk could be a AC lowering machine.  The only problem I can see is what slot(s) this thing will take up.  By the look of it, it should take up both a hand and a forearm slot.  But maybe we could fudge it a bit and just say hand slot.  I could not find a good cestus photo!<br />

<br /><br />Good question. The current 'weapons' for the monk use the bracer slot. Maybe these should use the same? Otherwise you might get people trying to use both... or is part of the point to let Monks use some of the other cool bracers out there?

What do you mean change the boots of the underdark? Not the image I hope. The picture is priceless. Have you no humor potential?

<br />What do you mean change the boots of the underdark? Not the image I hope. The picture is priceless. Have you no humor potential? <br />

<br /><br />I feel the same way... despite my "Keebler" jokes- I think it is fine as is.

<br />Don't stop. Your reviews are thorough and necessary. Do you need a job (lol)?<br />

<br /><br />LOL, I am a programmer. Often I spend a lot of time sitting around doing nothing while things are compiling or multi-hour database queries are running. It's the perfect time to scrutinize TD Tokens!  =D

<br />

<br />Don't stop. Your reviews are thorough and necessary. Do you need a job (lol)?<br />

<br /><br />LOL, I am a programmer. Often I spend a lot of time sitting around doing nothing while things are compiling or multi-hour database queries are running. It's the perfect time to scrutinize TD Tokens!  =D<br />

<br /><br />Ditto! That is exactly what I do... every time I have a long build process, or some other query... I come here and check! :-P