TOPIC: This is not the Post you are looking for Henwy. Move along.

Perhaps the solution for the charm would be to say "if the monster rolls a 20 you get 1 extra pull - limit 1 per person 1 per room).  As I can see someone carrying 2 or even 5 of these in a pocket and getting more.

Questor's Charm of Luck: 1 Extra token for each 20 slid during combat<br /><br />Does this count if another player slides a 20?  If so, than this is a good item for everyone.  If not, it really sucks for casters, and support characters. 

<br />Does anyone else feel that the effect of "draw an extra token" is contributing to the issues surrounding this token?<br />

At its current and expected power level, yielding one extra token on a slide of 20, it seems unlikely to be desired if it takes up a slot.

<br /> <br />Does anyone else feel that the effect of "draw an extra token" is contributing to the issues surrounding this token?<br /> <br />

<br /><br />Yes.

I wonder if the implication wasn't that if we changed What we got... then How we got it might not be such a big deal.

<br />In other words - it is the "how you get" not "what you get" that is the problem.<br />

<br /><br />It's a conflict of interest- it changes the goal of taking the monster down into "getting that extra token"... and because it is an individual's goal, it conflicts with the other individual's interests (i.e. survival or their "getting that extra token"). Usually taking the monster down unifies the group.<br /><br />Horn of Plenty does not create this schism... so what Gary said holds true.<br />