TOPIC: +2 Holy Greatsword question

The token says it's weildable by either a Fighter or Paladin, however I've heard rumors that the extra +3 vs evil enemies only kicks in if it's in a Paladin's hands. Can anyone confirm/deny?

That is not a rumor. It says it directly on the token. It also clearly states it in the description in the token guide.

In the hands of a paladin it does extra dmg vs.evil creatures be they Outsider, Undead etc. Other wise its just a spiffy +2 two-handed sword

really? I don't see it, the image I'm looking at on the 2007 version simply says

+2 Holy Greatsword
Barbarian Fighter & Paladin
(+3 damage to evil creatures)

Unfortunately the image on the Resources page is not correct. The image from the current Token Guide is, however, and it definitely says the +3 only comes into effect in the hands of a paladin.

Barbarian, Fighter, Paladin
(+3 dam. to evil creatures in hands of paladin)

The Token Guide further elaborates:

Holy Great Sword (+2): The +2 Holy Great Sword causes an additional 3HP damage against evil creatures if the sword is wielded by a Paladin. It is a normal +2 Great Sword if used by a Barbarian or Fighter.

gotcha, thanks for the update