TOPIC: Haunted Manor - Mirror Ritual Puzzle Question/Feedback (Spoiler tags used)

I immediately identified the whetstone and assumed it would go to the blacksmith (unfortunately this was also the clue from the rogue so it only told us what we already knew), but then there were a few other items that could also go with the blacksmith (nail and arrowhead). We couldn't find anything else that fit with the arrowhead, so we figured the blacksmith probably was the one that made the arrowhead.

Then we thought that the whetstone may go with the butcher/chef instead.

After that we thought the nail was maybe a coffin nail (?) so paired it with the gravedigger.

Pretty sure the rope was meant for the sailor-looking fellow, which meant the guy with the spyglass was something else (no clue on that one).

There were a couple "dapper" looking fellows, so we figured one of them would get the hand mirror, but had no idea which one.

There was the little hammer, so we thought since the knight was holding a big war hammer, it would go with him (though now that I think about it again, maybe it was supposed to be the arrowhead since it was a weapon, but I don't think that really fits a fully armored knight) We also had someone say it could have been a rock hammer, but we didn't see anyone who looked like a jeweler either. And then it would leave us wondering what to give the knight.

I can't remember the other 4 items now, but I think we were fairly confident on those since my memory seems fixated on these other items.

Please help if you solved the puzzle!

The whetstone went with the chef, as the rogue clue used the term ‘whet your appetite.’