TOPIC: 2025 Uncommon Tokens

Uncommon

Overall Looks Good

Necklace of Freyja: Underpowered compared to 2022 uncommon "Amulet of the Firehawk" which grants +2 damage to all ranged attacks (including spells) and is usable by everyone. It's OK, not every token has to be comparably good, but this could be +2 and still strictly worse than that token. I'd recommend bumping this to +2, or switching the effect to the Amulet of the Norns effect that occurs at Rare, which would convey that Wizards can get a usable-by-all-casters effect at a lower rarity.

Oil of Odin's Blessing: There may not be room for it, but for consistency the crit ability would be worded as "Negates undead Critical & Sneak Attack Immunity for your attacks"

Amulet of Odin: the word "total" feels especially awkward here. Perhaps:
"(Barbarian: +3 damage with 2H instead)" or simply
"(Barbarian: +3 instead)"

Brokkr's Amulet: not as bad as the above, but IMO still clearer with "instead"

Matthew Hayward wrote: Overall Looks Good

Necklace of Freyja: Underpowered compared to 2022 uncommon "Amulet of the Firehawk" which grants +2 damage to all ranged attacks (including spells) and is usable by everyone. It's OK, not every token has to be comparably good, but this could be +2 and still strictly worse than that token. I'd recommend bumping this to +2, or switching the effect to the Amulet of the Norns effect that occurs at Rare, which would convey that Wizards can get a usable-by-all-casters effect at a lower rarity.

Oil of Odin's Blessing: There may not be room for it, but for consistency the crit ability would be worded as "Negates undead Critical & Sneak Attack Immunity for your attacks"

I upped the damage bonus to +2. Thanks.

David Zych wrote: Amulet of Odin: the word "total" feels especially awkward here. Perhaps:
"(Barbarian: +3 damage with 2H instead)" or simply
"(Barbarian: +3 instead)"

Brokkr's Amulet: not as bad as the above, but IMO still clearer with "instead"

Good idea. Thanks.