TOPIC: A favor when reviewing things, s'il vous plaît

First off, we really, REALLY appreciate the efforts y'all put into reviewing tokens and other TD-related materials! We would not be able to have nearly the same level of polish without your amazing efforts. We just have a little favor to ask when you give us your comments: please try to be specific. I know I fall victim to this myself. Sometimes I forget that others don't have access to my internal monologues and I'll make a statement that doesn't make sense to a third party.

Here are some examples of the types of things that can be challenging:

• "This feels off" without saying why it feels off is very hard to interpret.
• "Can we change X" without saying what and/or why you think it should be changed kind of leaves us hanging.
• When quoting a token's text, please name the token--preferably by using the name on the token or some other patently-obvious name.
• Be careful when using acronyms and initialisms. It may not be apparent to others what it stands for unless the full name was previously referenced.
• When quoting text from a guide, naming the page, section, and paragraph number is super-helpful.

Again, y'all's reviews and comments are very much welcome and appreciated. We enjoy working together to make TD the best it can be, so thank you very much for your ongoing editorial support!

Great advice!

Can we change the +1 bonus though, it feels off to me.

Bumping this back to the first page.

Matthew Hayward wrote: Can we change the +1 bonus though, it feels off to me.