With the change to the eldritch cloak, will that coincide with a drop in the current proposed barrelbane (dropping the STR boost from a +6 to a +4?) - I know the barrelbane likely wasn’t listed yet because it’s still being tossed around in the ol’ brainmeats. I believe if the barrelbane bonus isn’t brought down, it will be generally more driven after than the eldritch. I still believe that with the kilts, a Pandora’s box was opened, and the pants slot went from being one of the weaker slots to one of the more incredibly powerful slots. Since I suspect token reprints are not something that is desired, I think ensuring the eldritch token is more desired than any of its component parts should be part of the design goal. I’m okay with the proposed change as is (the choose a +4, 5 hp) but only is if tethered to a drop in STR to the current proposed UR.
I don’t understand the add to rogue to the avenger - that seems against the general build. I think dropping the saves is fine, provided the intent is to bring them back with the upcoming relic/legendary in 2020. (I loved the idea of an updated paladin weapon, and loved seeing saves added to a weapon - it’s seemed thematic)
Happy about the hat being added to the recipe for blessed redoubt helm. I think it still is discordant with the prior dragonscale helm, as they are both UR and this is just an improved version (unless we are considering set bonuses in the initial build mix - even then, it basically is just a more available, better helm overall).
Do well and you will have no need for ancestors. - Voltaire