TOPIC: Flask of Sharing - Greater Alchemist Pouch

How does the +1 HP from Greater Alchemist Pouch interact with Flask of Sharing?

I would guess the Flask looks at the final HP the potion restores not the printed amount, but just would like to confirm that.

I would guess you can only use one or the other effect. Same as it works with the pouch of tulz

Could be. I would just like a ruling, I don't care what the ruling is.

Pouch and Flask feel like different slots, so it seems you should be able to use both.

My vote - if the person using the potion has the Pouch, it gets +1.

Then, the Flask triggers and divides it evenly.

That's similar to how resistance works; first you decrease the damage, then you divide it in half. I don't see it being a game breaker either way.

jedibcg wrote: How does the +1 HP from Greater Alchemist Pouch interact with Flask of Sharing?

I would guess the Flask looks at the final HP the potion restores not the printed amount, but just would like to confirm that.

Also, I assume that the non-healing benefits of the potion are not shared? Whether that be positive (e.g. Siren's Wine) or negative (e.g. Creeper Stout).

Can the Flask of Sharing be used to share with something who is unable to drink potions (e.g. someone who previously drank Thrall Ale)?

Incognito wrote:

jedibcg wrote: How does the +1 HP from Greater Alchemist Pouch interact with Flask of Sharing?

I would guess the Flask looks at the final HP the potion restores not the printed amount, but just would like to confirm that.

Also, I assume that the non-healing benefits of the potion are not shared? Whether that be positive (e.g. Siren's Wine) or negative (e.g. Creeper Stout).

Can the Flask of Sharing be used to share with something who is unable to drink potions (e.g. someone who previously drank Thrall Ale)?

Ohhh that is a good question too.

I'd also be tempted to fall on the side of the pouch doubles it and the flask splits it. Honestly doubling up on 1 point heals isn't going to be game breaking.

I'm more interested if the flask might remove side effects from potions. If you were do use the flask to split say a Potion Blessed Brandy would 1, both, or neither player also have their negative undead touch attack side effects removed?

Personally I'd fall on the side of neither since as I read it the flask is only using the input potions to determine how much it heals both targets but an official ruling would be great.

Picc wrote: I'd also be tempted to fall on the side of the pouch doubles it and the flask splits it. Honestly doubling up on 1 point heals isn't going to be game breaking.

I'm more interested if the flask might remove side effects from potions. If you were do use the flask to split say a Potion Blessed Brandy would 1, both, or neither player also have their negative undead touch attack side effects removed?

Personally I'd fall on the side of neither since as I read it the flask is only using the input potions to determine how much it heals both targets but an official ruling would be great.

Doubles it? You mean adds 1 HP if it is 1 already you could say it doubles but that is misleading because it does not double a 3HP potion.....just not wanting to confuse anyone that doesn't know what the pouch does.

I would imagine only the player equipped with the Pouch and the Flask would get the +1, but we'll have to see what TPTB say. Plenty of time before it becomes relevant.