TOPIC: Re-Print Suggestions for all Rarities

Picc wrote:

Endgame wrote:

SnakeEyes (Eric) wrote:

BeLinda Mathie wrote: UR
FoP: Tortoise

Rare
Potion Leaping Attack

+1 These reprints are also a great fit for the 2022 theme. I'm already imaginging swashbuckling leaps from one ship to another in battle!

Can we put Potion Leaping Attack on the never reprint list? It would, eventually, make having to balance builds between melee and ranged a real consideration.

Instead, perhaps, reprint Boots of Bounding?

100% disagree, I love potion of leap attack exactly because it lets me not have to worry. Heck can we have a permanent version that doesn't take up a crippling slot (looking at you fizzy lifting).

At that point, just discontinue missile tokens?

Endgame wrote:

Picc wrote:

Endgame wrote:

SnakeEyes (Eric) wrote:

BeLinda Mathie wrote: UR
FoP: Tortoise

Rare
Potion Leaping Attack

+1 These reprints are also a great fit for the 2022 theme. I'm already imaginging swashbuckling leaps from one ship to another in battle!

Can we put Potion Leaping Attack on the never reprint list? It would, eventually, make having to balance builds between melee and ranged a real consideration.

Instead, perhaps, reprint Boots of Bounding?

100% disagree, I love potion of leap attack exactly because it lets me not have to worry. Heck can we have a permanent version that doesn't take up a crippling slot (looking at you fizzy lifting).

At that point, just discontinue missile tokens?

Your being hyperbolic. By the same token, why not discontinue melee. Ranged can do anything melee can do, doesn't have to deal with retribution, frequently dungeons have a "no melee" monster, "no range" monsters what like once ever? dex also raises your defensive stats, "best" rogue build involves a crossbow, IOs is nuts, etc.

IMO as long as everyone can meaningfully participate in every room leap attack 1/room is just a different way to build.

Also compound weapons.

Not sure if this was mentioned earlier but...

2011's Lenses of Clear Sight - IF a new item is not created that can counteract displacement magic and mirror image effects.

Picc wrote:

Endgame wrote:

Picc wrote:

Endgame wrote:

SnakeEyes (Eric) wrote:

BeLinda Mathie wrote: UR
FoP: Tortoise

Rare
Potion Leaping Attack

+1 These reprints are also a great fit for the 2022 theme. I'm already imaginging swashbuckling leaps from one ship to another in battle!

Can we put Potion Leaping Attack on the never reprint list? It would, eventually, make having to balance builds between melee and ranged a real consideration.

Instead, perhaps, reprint Boots of Bounding?

100% disagree, I love potion of leap attack exactly because it lets me not have to worry. Heck can we have a permanent version that doesn't take up a crippling slot (looking at you fizzy lifting).

At that point, just discontinue missile tokens?

Your being hyperbolic. By the same token, why not discontinue melee. Ranged can do anything melee can do, doesn't have to deal with retribution, frequently dungeons have a "no melee" monster, "no range" monsters what like once ever? dex also raises your defensive stats, "best" rogue build involves a crossbow, IOs is nuts, etc.

IMO as long as everyone can meaningfully participate in every room leap attack 1/room is just a different way to build.

Also compound weapons.

Further, in order to use the potion you miss a round of combat OR you must own another $100-$150 token; the Pouch of Tulz. There were years when I burned stacks of them and they were going for $3 - $5 a piece. For those reasons, it's not a light decision to go strong on melee or a free ability by any means.

SnakeEyes (Eric) wrote: Further, in order to use the potion you miss a round of combat OR you must own another $100-$150 token; the Pouch of Tulz. There were years when I burned stacks of them and they were going for $3 - $5 a piece. For those reasons, it's not a light decision to go strong on melee or a free ability by any means.

Or belt, pants or gloves of retrieval.

NightGod wrote:

SnakeEyes (Eric) wrote: Further, in order to use the potion you miss a round of combat OR you must own another $100-$150 token; the Pouch of Tulz. There were years when I burned stacks of them and they were going for $3 - $5 a piece. For those reasons, it's not a light decision to go strong on melee or a free ability by any means.

Or belt, pants or gloves of retrieval.

The hat will work too, but only once / game of course.

How about a Topaz Trilliant reprint?

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: How about a Topaz Trilliant reprint?

Someone earlier in the thread suggested a reprint with a different damage type. Any attachment to - darkrift damage?

Endgame wrote:

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: How about a Topaz Trilliant reprint?

Someone earlier in the thread suggested a reprint with a different damage type. Any attachment to - darkrift damage?

Personally I would like to see a version with the minus to more common damage types like fire, cold, acid or something else. Darkrift is fairly uncommon as a damage type

I'm fine with whatever. Maybe Sacred, since we had sacredfirw recently?

Arcanist Kolixela wrote:

Endgame wrote:

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: How about a Topaz Trilliant reprint?

Someone earlier in the thread suggested a reprint with a different damage type. Any attachment to - darkrift damage?

Personally I would like to see a version with the minus to more common damage types like fire, cold, acid or something else. Darkrift is fairly uncommon as a damage type

On the other hand, most other damage types have had many tokens that reduce damage of that type. But this is one of the few that reduces darkrift. If we wanted something other than darkrift, I'd suggest another less-common type, like Acid or Poison.

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: I'm fine with whatever. Maybe Sacred, since we had sacredfirw recently?

Compound damage types need to stop happening. If the damage is supposed to be reducible but difficult, it should be half one type and half another (or some similar mix). And if it shouldn't be reducible, then just make it eldritch and be done.