TOPIC: Re-Print Suggestions for all Rarities

The list of requested reprints grows yearly.

I'm fine with 3 or 4 of them coming, as I'm sure they will anyhow.

Making some off limits completely feels a little extreme. I'd prefer the door be left open, even if only slightly, though it does make the process inefficient if there is an unofficial "never reprint" list.

Uncommon:
Commander's Holy Symbol
Holy Lager
Sacred Hand Grenade

Rare:
Potion Blessed Brandy and/or Salve of Shadowvein
Sacred Arrow (or munitions for whatever ranged weapon will be in print)
Sacred Runestone

Correct me if I’m wrong but didn’t we just get Holy Water this year?

Rare:
Scroll False Image
Ioun Stone Faceted Amber

Flik wrote: Correct me if I’m wrong but didn’t we just get Holy Water this year?

Indeed - removed.

edwin wrote: A couple of out of print hard to get URs for classes who have Legendaries starting this year.

Viper Strike Set items
Stu's Handy Stein

Repeat the cycle in subsequent years. This way more classes get new toys to play with each year.

The belt, pants, and weapon please, although if there is a crossbow added there would not be a need for two weapons. It would synergies with the IS from last year iirc.

Common:
tokendb.com/token/spiked-buckler/

Reprint Bowl of Spirit Sight, but open it to more classes. At a minimum Clerics, but I'd like to see all spellcasters or potentially all classes (the bowl is doing the work, right?)

If considered too powerful to be in more classes hands at Slotless, consider moving it to a FoP.

Maybe add some tokendb text for "can only be used after Bard or Rogue has failed their check, or character is not in party".

Fiddy wrote: Reprint Bowl of Spirit Sight, but open it to more classes. At a minimum Clerics, but I'd like to see all spellcasters or potentially all classes (the bowl is doing the work, right?)

If considered too powerful to be in more classes hands at Slotless, consider moving it to a FoP.

Maybe add some tokendb text for "can only be used after Bard or Rogue has failed their check, or character is not in party".

I suggested that in the form of FoP: Whispering Wind on the UR thread ^_^

Arcanist Kolixela wrote:

Fiddy wrote: Reprint Bowl of Spirit Sight, but open it to more classes. At a minimum Clerics, but I'd like to see all spellcasters or potentially all classes (the bowl is doing the work, right?)

If considered too powerful to be in more classes hands at Slotless, consider moving it to a FoP.

Maybe add some tokendb text for "can only be used after Bard or Rogue has failed their check, or character is not in party".

I suggested that in the form of FoP: Whispering Wind on the UR thread ^_^

If we repeat it often enough in enough different places, it might stick in Jeff's head as a good idea?

Or, it was 2 days since your post and I forgot?

I'm sure it was one of those two.

Fiddy wrote:

Arcanist Kolixela wrote:

Fiddy wrote: Reprint Bowl of Spirit Sight, but open it to more classes. At a minimum Clerics, but I'd like to see all spellcasters or potentially all classes (the bowl is doing the work, right?)

If considered too powerful to be in more classes hands at Slotless, consider moving it to a FoP.

Maybe add some tokendb text for "can only be used after Bard or Rogue has failed their check, or character is not in party".

I suggested that in the form of FoP: Whispering Wind on the UR thread ^_^

If we repeat it often enough in enough different places, it might stick in Jeff's head as a good idea?

Or, it was 2 days since your post and I forgot?

I'm sure it was one of those two.

Either or ^_^

Wade Schwendemann wrote: The list of requested reprints grows yearly.

I'm fine with 3 or 4 of them coming, as I'm sure they will anyhow.

Making some off limits completely feels a little extreme. I'd prefer the door be left open, even if only slightly, though it does make the process inefficient if there is an unofficial "never reprint" list.

There is kind of an official "never reprint" list, but I think there are only two tokens on it: Horn of Plenty and Amulet of Treasure Finding.

The only other tokens I recall Jeff mentioning any restrictions on reprinting are Relics, but it seems like there's a little wiggle room in that.

"I have no plans to do a complete reprint of any Relic, but we might eventually get around to making something that is sort of like an old one...so instead of a Ring that is +4 to saves, it might be +2 saves and +6 hit points.

Thanks for your input on all this. "

From Post #92 on this thread:

truedungeon.com/forum?view=topic&catid=570&id=245369&start=84#286216