TOPIC: Re-Print Suggestions for all Rarities

I'm all good with that.

I dont envy TPTB the decision of "reprint for newer players" vs. It isnt what we want around or dont want to disrupt new tokens

Matthew Hayward wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Arcanist Kolixela wrote:

BeLinda Mathie wrote: My reprint requests:

UR
Dougal's Cloak of the Stars (or functional reprint)
Ioun Stone Topaz Trilliant
Mithral Gauntlets
Nightshade's +2 Short Sword

Rare
+1 Sling
Ring of Brilliance
Ring of Reflexes

I agree with everything on the list.

Honestly I think Jeff either needs to reprint the Mithral Gauntlets or he needs to state officially that they will never be reprinted because they come up on the list constantly.

I would say the most asked for reprints are
1. Mithral Gauntlets
2. +2 Sacred Sling
3. Shield of the Scholar
4. Mad Evoker's Charm
5. Gloves of the Flying Fist
6. +2 Staff of Power
7. Nightshade's +2 Short Sword

Not necessarily in that order.

Newer tokens that seem to have become recently popular include
Earcuff of Orbits
Ioun Stobe Topaz Trilliant
Ioun Stone Sapphire Prism
Assassin's Crossbow

I have never seen a volunteer token or completion token reprinted. The closest was boots of shocking vs. Inferno step.

Not has a UR token been reprinted once it became part of a legendary recipie unless one counts the +1 mighty shortbow, which isnt a specific requirement.

I'd like to see an Ekdtar's reprint.
Charm Necklace would be nice.
Druegar's death die would likely be quite popular.
All the class specific FoPs, specifically owl and phoenix, though I'm also in the market for dragon and tortoise.
I'd like UR Special, but I suspect I'm in the minority.

Topaz trilliant is a 2012 token - making it one of the older ones.

I’d prefer to see it not reprinted though because it steps on the volunteer ioun from... 2017?

But does it step on it? They do stack after all, someone can have both.

Mike Steele wrote:

Matthew Hayward wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Arcanist Kolixela wrote:

BeLinda Mathie wrote: My reprint requests:

UR
Dougal's Cloak of the Stars (or functional reprint)
Ioun Stone Topaz Trilliant
Mithral Gauntlets
Nightshade's +2 Short Sword

Rare
+1 Sling
Ring of Brilliance
Ring of Reflexes

I agree with everything on the list.

Honestly I think Jeff either needs to reprint the Mithral Gauntlets or he needs to state officially that they will never be reprinted because they come up on the list constantly.

I would say the most asked for reprints are
1. Mithral Gauntlets
2. +2 Sacred Sling
3. Shield of the Scholar
4. Mad Evoker's Charm
5. Gloves of the Flying Fist
6. +2 Staff of Power
7. Nightshade's +2 Short Sword

Not necessarily in that order.

Newer tokens that seem to have become recently popular include
Earcuff of Orbits
Ioun Stobe Topaz Trilliant
Ioun Stone Sapphire Prism
Assassin's Crossbow

I have never seen a volunteer token or completion token reprinted. The closest was boots of shocking vs. Inferno step.

Not has a UR token been reprinted once it became part of a legendary recipie unless one counts the +1 mighty shortbow, which isnt a specific requirement.

I'd like to see an Ekdtar's reprint.
Charm Necklace would be nice.
Druegar's death die would likely be quite popular.
All the class specific FoPs, specifically owl and phoenix, though I'm also in the market for dragon and tortoise.
I'd like UR Special, but I suspect I'm in the minority.

Topaz trilliant is a 2012 token - making it one of the older ones.

I’d prefer to see it not reprinted though because it steps on the volunteer ioun from... 2017?

But does it step on it? They do stack after all, someone can have both.

By “step on” I mean “reduce desirability at least a moderate amount.”

Having a token that is strictly better than another one steps on it, unless you believe anyone who equips one would choose to equip the other.

Which I don’t believe is the case for these two.

Mithral Gauntlets
Mad Evoker's Charm
FoP: Panther
Ektdar's Tinkering Tool
Cloak of Destiny/Dougal's

Basic gold pieces/gems

Matthew Hayward wrote:

Mike Steele wrote:

Matthew Hayward wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Arcanist Kolixela wrote:

BeLinda Mathie wrote: My reprint requests:

UR
Dougal's Cloak of the Stars (or functional reprint)
Ioun Stone Topaz Trilliant
Mithral Gauntlets
Nightshade's +2 Short Sword

Rare
+1 Sling
Ring of Brilliance
Ring of Reflexes

I agree with everything on the list.

Honestly I think Jeff either needs to reprint the Mithral Gauntlets or he needs to state officially that they will never be reprinted because they come up on the list constantly.

I would say the most asked for reprints are
1. Mithral Gauntlets
2. +2 Sacred Sling
3. Shield of the Scholar
4. Mad Evoker's Charm
5. Gloves of the Flying Fist
6. +2 Staff of Power
7. Nightshade's +2 Short Sword

Not necessarily in that order.

Newer tokens that seem to have become recently popular include
Earcuff of Orbits
Ioun Stobe Topaz Trilliant
Ioun Stone Sapphire Prism
Assassin's Crossbow

I have never seen a volunteer token or completion token reprinted. The closest was boots of shocking vs. Inferno step.

Not has a UR token been reprinted once it became part of a legendary recipie unless one counts the +1 mighty shortbow, which isnt a specific requirement.

I'd like to see an Ekdtar's reprint.
Charm Necklace would be nice.
Druegar's death die would likely be quite popular.
All the class specific FoPs, specifically owl and phoenix, though I'm also in the market for dragon and tortoise.
I'd like UR Special, but I suspect I'm in the minority.

Topaz trilliant is a 2012 token - making it one of the older ones.

I’d prefer to see it not reprinted though because it steps on the volunteer ioun from... 2017?

But does it step on it? They do stack after all, someone can have both.

By “step on” I mean “reduce desirability at least a moderate amount.”

Having a token that is strictly better than another one steps on it, unless you believe anyone who equips one would choose to equip the other.

Which I don’t believe is the case for these two.

Well, I disagree. I think Topaz Trilliant and Tanzanite Sphere are both quite tough to cut.

It'll be tougher with the ISPN, but I think they will both still make it for Epic. Saves>>>AC, imo.

Wade Schwendemann wrote: I'd like UR Special, but I suspect I'm in the minority.

If you make the 2021 special ability flip for Mithral coin of fate, I’m 100% on board.

Thinking of another one, Bracers of Supreme Archery may be good as it's an enabler for anyone who wants to try making a ranged build. It also fits into a slot where there are quite a few tokens to choose from in a BiS build so should help build diversity if it's reprinted.

Iross wrote: Thinking of another one, Bracers of Supreme Archery may be good as it's an enabler for anyone who wants to try making a ranged build. It also fits into a slot where there are quite a few tokens to choose from in a BiS build so should help build diversity if it's reprinted.

While ai agree with your statements, it too would be the first UR reprinted that was a legendary ingredient after it was reprinted.

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Iross wrote: Thinking of another one, Bracers of Supreme Archery may be good as it's an enabler for anyone who wants to try making a ranged build. It also fits into a slot where there are quite a few tokens to choose from in a BiS build so should help build diversity if it's reprinted.

While ai agree with your statements, it too would be the first UR reprinted that was a legendary ingredient after it was reprinted.

I'm curious, who is actually opposed to reprinting URs that are part of a Legendary recipe? Is the rationale that it will make the Legendary less scarce/valuable because more can be made from existing relics?

I personally wouldn't rule any such URs out of the Reprint suggestions unless TD comes out with a statement that those aren't going to be reprinted. I don't think that's ever even been hinted at.

Mike Steele wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Iross wrote: Thinking of another one, Bracers of Supreme Archery may be good as it's an enabler for anyone who wants to try making a ranged build. It also fits into a slot where there are quite a few tokens to choose from in a BiS build so should help build diversity if it's reprinted.

While ai agree with your statements, it too would be the first UR reprinted that was a legendary ingredient after it was reprinted.

I'm curious, who is actually opposed to reprinting URs that are part of a Legendary recipe? Is the rationale that it will make the Legendary less scarce/valuable because more can be made from existing relics?

I personally wouldn't rule any such URs out of the Reprint suggestions unless TD comes out with a statement that those aren't going to be reprinted. I don't think that's ever even been hinted at.

I think it’s just that it’s never been done before. I really hope there isn’t a rule against it, because with legendaries now needing 2 URs to build, the list of URs used as ingredients is getting quite large

Edit, one thought for this year.

Given the pandemic, VTD, and the new legendaries that need to be designed, maybe a much larger percentage of URs should be reprints this year?

Mike Steele wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Iross wrote: Thinking of another one, Bracers of Supreme Archery may be good as it's an enabler for anyone who wants to try making a ranged build. It also fits into a slot where there are quite a few tokens to choose from in a BiS build so should help build diversity if it's reprinted.

While ai agree with your statements, it too would be the first UR reprinted that was a legendary ingredient after it was reprinted.

I'm curious, who is actually opposed to reprinting URs that are part of a Legendary recipe? Is the rationale that it will make the Legendary less scarce/valuable because more can be made from existing relics?

I personally wouldn't rule any such URs out of the Reprint suggestions unless TD comes out with a statement that those aren't going to be reprinted. I don't think that's ever even been hinted at.

The fact that it hasn't happened yet is at least a hint that it might never.

I'm not opposed to it so much as I was pointing out a fact.

I don't care if things are or aren't reprinted. I kind of expect that any tokens I like may be reprinted.

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Mike Steele wrote:

Wade Schwendemann wrote:

Iross wrote: Thinking of another one, Bracers of Supreme Archery may be good as it's an enabler for anyone who wants to try making a ranged build. It also fits into a slot where there are quite a few tokens to choose from in a BiS build so should help build diversity if it's reprinted.

While ai agree with your statements, it too would be the first UR reprinted that was a legendary ingredient after it was reprinted.

I'm curious, who is actually opposed to reprinting URs that are part of a Legendary recipe? Is the rationale that it will make the Legendary less scarce/valuable because more can be made from existing relics?

I personally wouldn't rule any such URs out of the Reprint suggestions unless TD comes out with a statement that those aren't going to be reprinted. I don't think that's ever even been hinted at.

The fact that it hasn't happened yet is at least a hint that it might never.

I'm not opposed to it so much as I was pointing out a fact.

I don't care if things are or aren't reprinted. I kind of expect that any tokens I like may be reprinted.

Sure. I understand that the fact that none have been reprinted yet could either be a hint that they might not be, or just a coincidence. I'd recommend going ahead and putting them in recommended reprint lists, and let TPTB say if that's a no-go.