TOPIC: FINAL Transmute Images

Jeff321 wrote:

MasterED wrote:

Cranston wrote: So this is compatible with any one of these, or any one of those, but this is not compatible with that, but that's ok, because these aren't compatible with that either. Those are compatible with that, but not with these, but can be compatible with this, so long as it's only one of those, and there are none of these, but that's ok, because those aren't compatible with these anyway. And I used to think COBOL was cumbersome.

I do thank you and all the character creators for without you our job would be miserable! I understand how this isn't ideal (being in IT/software) but I do think it is best for the game and new players getting them to transmute and collect treasure.

Hope it isn't too difficult for you.

Ed

I feel your pain on that. Just reading the coach's guide on how to calculate treasure today is enough to give one a headache! And Gold Nugget, Charm of Treasure Boosting, and Crown of Treasure Finding all will need to be added.

The rate we are going, we'll need a spreadsheet or app to compute treasure so that you have a value to put in on the main spreadsheet or app. I'm not sure why treasure needs to be so complicated.

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

Picc wrote:

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

Definitely worth it!

Picc wrote:

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

At this point the only good news i'm hearing is the potential for multiple beads. Was hoping to get to the +3 since there's no change on the kilt. I'm glad i went for my URTE's but have fun with the teeth.

Matt wrote:

Picc wrote:

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

At this point the only good news i'm hearing is the potential for multiple beads. Was hoping to get to the +3 since there's no change on the kilt. I'm glad i went for my URTE's but have fun with the teeth.

Ya multiple beads should be cool

Just change the "or"s to ands and the kilt will be great!

Picc wrote:

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

Kilt is fine as is.

Rob F wrote:

Picc wrote:

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

Kilt is fine as is.

That’s one opinion

Picc wrote:

Xavon wrote:

Mike Steele wrote: Jeff, I wish you could change the Kilt so that the UR Kilts aren't situationally better than the Transmuted Kilt. Otherwise it looks great.

+1, but i guess the ship has sailed...

+2 but I've also about given up either getting the kilt or an 11th hour change. At this point I'm just trying to decide if it's still worth finishing the teeth as my sole eldritched but I probably will for fear of missing out on the cool event.

+3

I was excited to make my first Eldritch item but now I'm considering not even making it at all. Whether it's balanced or not it just feels like it's a downgrade. It doesn't matter that it's "only" a three year item. That's a long time and a large portion of my token budget and it should be a no-brainer to replace the UR with the Eldritch.

As someone who is primarily interested in DEX The UR is just better. It's much easier to mitigate -2 STR -2 CON in my build than it's going to be to make up for the loss of 2 DEX going to the Eldritch Kilt. CON players still get the benefits of +6 CON (ok, it's one less FORT).

In that vein, +4 to your choice stat, +5 HP, +1 to hit sounds more fair. Then everyone gets the feel of the +6 with a little sacrificed in saves.

Though I'm sure it's too late to change anything. As it currently stands I'm disappointed in the Kilt.

Suggestions to Text:

Charm of Treasure Boosting - Not a fan of "(& no CoA)". If you can fit it suggest changing text to: "+1 Treasure Chip. Cannot equip CoA. Can only equip one other Treasure Enhancer"

Necklace of the Sneak - Based on what I see on other UR Tokens the 19-20 should have the " " around it. So as now it should read: SA Criticals on "19-20". However, instead of SA I'd prefer the words Sneak Attack be written out and Criticals shortened to Crits. Think it's more intuitive this way. So proposed: Sneak Attack Crits on "19-20"....

Nightshade's Sneaky Necklace - Missing the word "on" like you have in the Relic. So should read: SA Criticals on 17-20. And still missing the " " around the 17-20. Keeping with my proposal above I would prefer it read: Sneak Attack Crits on "17-20"...

Last thing, I'm still not a fan of this wording in the Bard instruments "may take certain other actions". This is vague. Proposed changes to Relic "Bardsong +1/+1, may take certain other actions (see tokendb.com)"
Proposed changes to Legendary "Bardsong +2/+2, may take certain other actions (see tokendb.com) and re-roll saves of 1-3 (1/game)". Note I changed the word "save" to "saves", should be plural

Rob F wrote: Suggestions to Text:

Charm of Treasure Boosting - Not a fan of "(& no CoA)". If you can fit it suggest changing text to: "+1 Treasure Chip. Cannot equip CoA. Can only equip one other Treasure Enhancer"

How about

+1 treasure total when equiped with another UR or lower TE. (Max X chips)

Since at some point there will probably be another relic/legendary TE we might not want this to stack with.

Picc wrote:

Rob F wrote: Suggestions to Text:

Charm of Treasure Boosting - Not a fan of "(& no CoA)". If you can fit it suggest changing text to: "+1 Treasure Chip. Cannot equip CoA. Can only equip one other Treasure Enhancer"

How about

+1 treasure total when equiped with another UR or lower TE. (Max X chips)

Since at some point there will probably be another relic/legendary TE we might not want this to stack with.

Very valid concern. Your suggestion doesn’t address multiple UR’s though.