TOPIC: 2022 Uncommon Final Kind of

Thank you for your help to finalize the tokens ASAP.

truedungeon.com/files/Uncommon.jpg

Is the Sacred Cup slotless?

Is Sacred Cup slotless?
If so, it's a nice cleric version of Greater Mistletoe. Glad to see it.
If not, perhaps it should be.

Conch Horn of Courage

I understand why the change got made, but consider that the damage bonus is now not only greater than a number of ultrarares but greater than the legendary.

if stuck due to other tokens, can be +2 melee dmg and immunity to Fear, which doesn't appear to exist on any instrument in the game yet (just on earcuffs when bardsong is played).

Love the safety slug

Conch seems too good.

Thrilled about the improvement to Cloak of Sneaking.

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: Love the safety slug

Conch seems too good.

Thrilled about the improvement to Cloak of Sneaking.

I thought that about conch, but it's only to melee damage. I think I can talk myself into being OK with that. Maybe it needs a negative of some sort? +3 melee damage, -1 melee hit?

NightGod wrote:

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: Love the safety slug

Conch seems too good.

Thrilled about the improvement to Cloak of Sneaking.

I thought that about conch, but it's only to melee damage. I think I can talk myself into being OK with that. Maybe it needs a negative of some sort? +3 melee damage, -1 melee hit?

Conch looks fine to me. Compare to:

tokendb.com/token/magnificent-bards-instrument/

+2 dmg to melee and ranged attacks, 2018

To my eyes, Sacred Cup is more OP =X (if it's slotless anyway)

NightGod wrote: Is Sacred Cup slotless?
If so, it's a nice cleric version of Greater Mistletoe. Glad to see it.
If not, perhaps it should be.

agreed, especially since a lot of healing occurs out of combat.

Out of combat, there's no good thematic reason you couldn't put down your shield, pick up a cup, and cast the healing spell.

For healing during combat, there might be a thematic reason to require off-hand slot, but that requires us to keep track of a different +heal bonus for in combat vs out of combat. Which I will 100% totally do if that's the ruling, but either way please clarify.

NightGod wrote:

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: Love the safety slug

Conch seems too good.

Thrilled about the improvement to Cloak of Sneaking.

I thought that about conch, but it's only to melee damage. I think I can talk myself into being OK with that. Maybe it needs a negative of some sort? +3 melee damage, -1 melee hit?

Haha makes bad music so it lowers your hit but makes you oh so angry 👍

Miathan wrote:

NightGod wrote:

Wade Schwendemann (Dr. Uid) wrote: Love the safety slug

Conch seems too good.

Thrilled about the improvement to Cloak of Sneaking.

I thought that about conch, but it's only to melee damage. I think I can talk myself into being OK with that. Maybe it needs a negative of some sort? +3 melee damage, -1 melee hit?

Haha makes bad music so it lowers your hit but makes you oh so angry 👍

I mean, that would be my reaction to someone playing "Boogie Shoes" on the conch!!

Ian Lee wrote: Conch Horn of Courage

I understand why the change got made, but consider that the damage bonus is now not only greater than a number of ultrarares but greater than the legendary.

if stuck due to other tokens, can be +2 melee dmg and immunity to Fear, which doesn't appear to exist on any instrument in the game yet (just on earcuffs when bardsong is played).

Agreed this Seems OP at +3 Melee Damage, Not to make Lyre of the Siren obsolete, but Maybe this could be +1 All Damage Bardsong and Allows Bard to breathe underwater as long as they are singing. (obv it would also allow underwater bardsong as part of that effect)

Is the Sacred Cup Slotless? Sorry, had to...

I assume it will be but I feel like that should be marked for clarity unless it's an off-hand item, then it would need the 1H marker on it.

Does this suggest we may see a Legendary Grail of sorts in the future?