Welcome, Guest
Username: Password: Remember me

TOPIC: Current list of reprint requests

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #13

Please add me as 'Pro' for the Death Die, and I noticed that the Sacred Sling is missing the "(+4)" next to it.

I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Last edit: by Aothos.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #14

Add me +1 for:

Charm of Brooching
+2 Sacred Sling
Druegar’s Death Die
Amulet of Wonder

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #15

Bump me in for Questor’s Charm of Luck, +2 Sacred Sling, Sniper’s Spectacles, Druegar’s Death Die, and Charm of Brooching as a +1.
Lady Headshot herself

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #16

Wade put me down for reprint everything but I am against all reprints!

Seriously, thanks for volunteering to do this opinion "record keeping" it is why the True Dungeon community is so great!

Ed
Useful Links:
TD Character Creator
Amorgen's Excel Char Gen Tool
Token DataBase
Talking TD Podcast

TD Accomplishments:
Member of the first team to survive Epic True Grind
1st Solo NM as Poly Druid
Proud member of Gas Station Sushi
Don't Nerf Our Tokens!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #17

Aothos wrote: I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).


Yes to Cloak. If it looked like a Dracula cloak, that would be pretty cool.

I feel pretty mixed about the bear claws idea. So many polymorph druids already use Stu's Handy Stein. Others use Baton for the damage bump in polymorph. Plus, if the item that's polymorphing the druid is already in the mainhand slot- isn't it just a weapon at that point?

Adding variety is good as it diversifies builds, but the damage wheel would have to be something pretty good. Coronet already has a 9.5 average. Giving a monk a ~9.5 damage wheel at UR doesn't seem correct.
"IMHO we like to solve problems here on the forums that are only perceived problems due to a myopic view." -Bob C

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Last edit: by dokkaebi.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #18

Aothos wrote: Please add me as 'Pro' for the Death Die, and I noticed that the Sacred Sling is missing the "(+4)" next to it.

I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).


I agree with this, the Coronet isn't high demand due to the head slot and sacrifice of two spells (which I don't believe any other token requires) I'd prefer an improved token in a different slot. Maybe Figurine.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Last edit: by Mike Steele.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #19

Mike Steele wrote:

Aothos wrote: Please add me as 'Pro' for the Death Die, and I noticed that the Sacred Sling is missing the "(+4)" next to it.

I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).


I agree with this, the Coronet isn't high demand due to the head slot and sacrifice of two spells (which I don't believe any other token requires) I'd prefer an improved token in a different slot. Maybe Figurine.


Figurine could really work here too, and it would give druids a unique figurine.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #20

Arnold wrote:

Aothos wrote: I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).


Yes to Cloak. If it looked like a Dracula cloak, that would be pretty cool.

I feel pretty mixed about the bear claws idea. So many polymorph druids already use Stu's Handy Stein. Others use Baton for the damage bump in polymorph. Plus, if the item that's polymorphing the druid is already in the mainhand slot- isn't it just a weapon at that point?

Adding variety is good as it diversifies builds, but the damage wheel would have to be something pretty good. Coronet already has a 9.5 average. Giving a monk a ~9.5 damage wheel at UR doesn't seem correct.


+1 Bump for Dracula Cape

Envision this, as a quick fix to that problem on the Bear Claws: What if the dmg wheel had two sets of numbers on it, one in black (normal dmg, for anyone that uses them, i.e. monks, fighter, etc.) and purple numbers representing the polymorphed creature (either situated between the black numbers, or just above/below them). Since Polymorphing is announced the DM just switches which color he looks at. Now Jeff can create a balanced, and still viable, UR weapon usable by monks, fighters, and barbarians, but give it an edge geared towards Druids (and a little for monks).

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #21

Aothos wrote:

Arnold wrote:

Aothos wrote: I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).


Yes to Cloak. If it looked like a Dracula cloak, that would be pretty cool.

I feel pretty mixed about the bear claws idea. So many polymorph druids already use Stu's Handy Stein. Others use Baton for the damage bump in polymorph. Plus, if the item that's polymorphing the druid is already in the mainhand slot- isn't it just a weapon at that point?

Adding variety is good as it diversifies builds, but the damage wheel would have to be something pretty good. Coronet already has a 9.5 average. Giving a monk a ~9.5 damage wheel at UR doesn't seem correct.


+1 Bump for Dracula Cape

Envision this, as a quick fix to that problem on the Bear Claws: What if the dmg wheel had two sets of numbers on it, one in black (normal dmg, for anyone that uses them, i.e. monks, fighter, etc.) and purple numbers representing the polymorphed creature (either situated between the black numbers, or just above/below them). Since Polymorphing is announced the DM just switches which color he looks at. Now Jeff can create a balanced, and still viable, UR weapon usable by monks, fighters, and barbarians, but give it an edge geared towards Druids (and a little for monks).


Or just include text +3 polymorph damage
this is not a signature.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #22

kurtreznor wrote:

Aothos wrote:

Arnold wrote:

Aothos wrote: I'd also like to be noted as against a reprint of the Coronet of the ArchDruid, with the suggestion of printing an item that polymorphs the player as well, but in a different slot. Maybe a cloak that turns you into a giant Bat or a pair of Bear Claws per the weapon (usable by the monk with furry of blows, but can polymorph the Druid if a spell surge is sacrificed; this would keep Druids from stacking Focus items (baton) and trade spell dmg for melee like the original).


Yes to Cloak. If it looked like a Dracula cloak, that would be pretty cool.

I feel pretty mixed about the bear claws idea. So many polymorph druids already use Stu's Handy Stein. Others use Baton for the damage bump in polymorph. Plus, if the item that's polymorphing the druid is already in the mainhand slot- isn't it just a weapon at that point?

Adding variety is good as it diversifies builds, but the damage wheel would have to be something pretty good. Coronet already has a 9.5 average. Giving a monk a ~9.5 damage wheel at UR doesn't seem correct.


+1 Bump for Dracula Cape

Envision this, as a quick fix to that problem on the Bear Claws: What if the dmg wheel had two sets of numbers on it, one in black (normal dmg, for anyone that uses them, i.e. monks, fighter, etc.) and purple numbers representing the polymorphed creature (either situated between the black numbers, or just above/below them). Since Polymorphing is announced the DM just switches which color he looks at. Now Jeff can create a balanced, and still viable, UR weapon usable by monks, fighters, and barbarians, but give it an edge geared towards Druids (and a little for monks).


Or just include text +3 polymorph damage


I like this quick fix suggestion; I think I'll create a rough draft after work this evening and post if here.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #23

Still hoping for a Polymorph cloak instead of a mainhand. Looking forward to what you draft up, though.
"IMHO we like to solve problems here on the forums that are only perceived problems due to a myopic view." -Bob C

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Current list of reprint requests 5 years 7 months ago #24

Arnold wrote: Still hoping for a Polymorph cloak instead of a mainhand. Looking forward to what you draft up, though.


I would also prefer a non-weapon, as that lets it be a bit more powerful/interesting since it requires using another slot.

But i was thinking maybe:
Glasses- eye of the tiger
Shirt or armor- sheeps clothing (polymorph into wolf)
this is not a signature.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.100 seconds