TOPIC: 2009 Ultra Rare Tokens <Feedback Please

I second (or third) the comment that the Dragonscale Shield should have the Druid class listed on it.  

<br />I second (or third) the comment that the Dragonscale Shield should have the Druid class listed on it.  <br />

<br /><br />Will do.

More on the charm after having read the posts:<br /><br />Oh come on!  I haven't hit a 20 yet!  I'm now going to hit 3 in one combat?!?<br /><br />Worthless, worthless, worthless.<br /><br /><br />Also, what about a puzzle room with a treasure box?  Are we totally getting away from rewarding the people who like puzzles over hack 'n slash?<br /><br />Even more for the poor DM to keep track of.  Let's just simplfy this and make it one additional draw.  Definitely a high seller then!!!!<br />

I like the charm. I figure I can hit at least 1 20 per combat on average.

I'll only take one if it's dipped in chocolate first

<br />Yes, it does 0.2 points better damage, but the Fighter may also get jumped by 8 Stirges in a room.  I think it is a fair trade off.<br />

<br /><br />YIKES! Its like becoming an all-you-can-eat Stirge Buffet!<br /><br />AND I want a photo of some poor guy with eight stuffed critters around his neck!

Since the DM won't check what weapon you have until you actually slide it, I figure most fighters will just keep quiet and not take the attacks.

They will if the wizard bought the sword for them.

Perhaps the Fighter can have a box on the party card like the Rogue does for the thieves tools.

Regarding the Charm, please keep in mind that it does not take a slot away from anything.  It is slotless.  <br /><br />Carrying one will get you a few extra tokens per run if you are a good slider -- at no "slot" cost.  It's like free money, baby!<br /><br />And you just know this is going to happen:  You decide not to carry one -- and you slide three 20's in one combat!<br /><br />BTW, the Coach can just put a little "+" next to the class on the Party Card if they are carrying a Charm.  The DM's can see that easily.  <br /><br />This should make sliding those "20"s even more fun -- and tempt people into going for that hard "20" instead of the easy "16" that would hit anyway.  I think this will make things a wee bit more interesting.<br /><br />Sorry if you didn't get your second Horn of Plenty.<br /><br /><br /><br />

<br />Mithral Helmet - thought the idea was to let the Ranger wear this so that the Ranger class could complete the Mithral set.  I would let the Ranger wear it.<br />

<br />I second that.  I thought the set was designed with the Ranger in mind.  If the concern is it is too much of an AC bump to the Ranger, consider lowering the AC Gain to +1 and up the effect to immune to fear and undead mind control.

Speaking of the horn of plenty, for the sake of us embryos, are you going to reprint the hop every 3 years, like the other ultra rares that are in demand? There are some of us out there that are only willing to pay TD the big bucks for tokens, not upwards of $200 for the hop on Ebay.